You might think there’s no safer place underwater than snugged to the side of the largest fish on Earth. But you would be wrong.
Divers watched in awe as a particularly persistent bird called a cormorant dove below the waves and ripped off suckerfish that were stuck to a whale shark. The video was shot in 2011 by the Manta Scuba Diving company but recently resurfaced on Facebook.
“I’ve been working on whale sharks for 25 years, and I’ve never seen that before,” says Brad Norman, a National Geographic Explorer and one of the world’s foremost experts on whale sharks.
“And I’ve been swimming with whale sharks thousands of times. Literally thousands of times.”
Remoras, or suckerfish, make a living by following larger animals around and eating their scraps. Some even appear to subsist on dung. In fact, these fish have been hitchhiking on sharks, whales, turtles, and manatee relatives called dugongs for so long that they’ve evolved strong suction cups on their foreheads in place of dorsal fins.
And yet, no one had ever seen a cormorant snatch a suckerfish off a whale shark.
Friend Or Foe?
In the wild, everything gets eaten by something eventually. And animals will often make use of novel food sources when opportunity knocks.
Cormorants, for instance, boast hooked beaks and large, webbed feet which allow them to dive below the surface and snipe fish. Some of these birds have even been seen plunging as deep as a 13-story building is tall.
But the cormorant video raises an interesting question: Would getting rid of a hanger-on such as a suckerfish be beneficial to the whale shark?
Mark Meekan, a research scientist with the Australian Institute of Marine Science, says he and his colleagues have been working to quantify the amount of drag a remora adds to its host as it moves through the water, much as the shape of a car affects its aerodynamics.
One or two remora would be unlikely to slow down a 40-foot whale shark, says Meekan, but when you start adding more and more remoras, those costs can add up. Sometimes, you can see as many as a hundred or more remoras plastered to the side of one shark.
“You’ve got to consider that whale sharks live on an energetic knife-edge,” says Meekan. Every little bit of energy counts.
Norman says the opposite may also be true; remoras could also help whale sharks. After all, it’s thought that suckerfish help keep whale shark skin clean of tiny crustaceans called copepods and other parasites.
“Sometimes I think the shark actually benefits from having suckerfish on board,” he says.
“Nature Keeps Surprising Us”
Right now, it’s impossible to say how widespread the new cormorant feeding behavior may be—it could just be the fancy of one bird in Mexico. But Meekan suspects the video may hint at a more common situation.
The Year of the Bird
In 1918 Congress passed the Migratory Bird Treaty Act to protect birds from wanton killing. To celebrate the centennial, National Geographic is partnering with the National Audubon Society, BirdLife International, and the Cornell Lab of Ornithology to declare 2018 the Year of the Bird. Sign the pledge to find out this month's action and share your actions using #BirdYourWorld to increase your impact.
We know, for instance, that reef sharks will sometimes take a swipe at remoras, says Meekan. He’s seen video from French Polynesia that appears to show whale sharks going into a cleaning posture—head up, tail down—to allow reef sharks to swarm all over them and gobble down remoras.
So perhaps whale sharks regularly offer themselves up for cleaning services.
“The thing is that whale sharks don’t need to come to the surface. They are breathing with a gill,” says Meekan. “Whale sharks may be coming into reefs to get clean all the time. It’s just happening at depths and in places where we simply don’t dive.”
If a tree falls in the woods, in other words.
“Whale sharks are the biggest fish in the sea, but there’s so much we’re still finding out about them,” says Norman. “It’s just another example of how nature keeps surprising us.”