Fur Farms Still Unfashionably Cruel, Critics Say

Animals in China have few protections. Will efforts elsewhere to make the industry more humane go far enough?

Fur seems to be making a high fashion comeback, the September issue of National Geographic reports. “The current revival is a story of the fur trade responding to its critics and often outmaneuvering them, combined with increased demand from the newly wealthy in China, South Korea, and Russia,” writes Richard Conniff.

After the animal welfare movement hit a high-water mark in the 1990s, the movement has lost some ground. Nearly two-thirds of women’s 2016 fall fashion collections featured fur, according to the International Fur Federation.

Less clear is the extent to which fur use has filtered down to the general population, and with China and Russia’s economies slowing, there are signs the industry has lost some momentum recently. This year the global fur industry is projecting a 33 percent drop in production—about 54 million minks worldwide compared to 72 million in 2015, reports Kopenhagen Fur, the world’s largest fur auction house.

Many different animals can be raised in captivity for the fur trade: minks, foxes, chinchillas, and raccoon dogs (also known as tanuki or Asiatic raccoons). They’re in addition to the myriad species that are trapped from the wild, including bobcats, beavers, lynxes, sables, seals, and weasels.

Mink is by far the most popular farmed fur, and Chinese minks dominate the market. In 2014, the country produced 35 million pelts, according to the International Fur Federation. But Chinese fur farming is virtually unregulated when it comes to animal welfare.

Chinese farms are often small, family-owned operations, according to a 2010 U.S. Department of Agriculture report. A 2005 report by Care for the Wild, a U.K.-based animal welfare nonprofit, found animals that were kept in small, dirty cages exposed to the rain and sun, experienced rough handling, and suffered high infant mortality rates. The report’s authors, investigators from Swiss Animal Protection and EAST International, observed abnormal behaviors indicative of poor welfare, including extreme fearfulness, unresponsiveness, and self-mutilation. And farmers reported infanticide and difficulty breeding, which are also signs of poor welfare.

Cheap labor and a lax regulations in China have allowed fur farming to grow, according to a paper published in 2010 by the Animal Legal and Historical Center at Michigan State University College of Law, which means that many more animals are likely subjected to inhumane conditions. “China has virtually no regulations protecting such animals,” writes Lesley Peterson, the paper’s author.

In the European Union, a new animal welfare regime called WelFur, developed by the fur industry in 2009, will roll out next year. WelFur will score mink farms on qualities such as health, behavior, and housing.

Animal welfare advocates, almost all of whom support a total ban on fur farming, are critical of the effort, which was developed and will be carried out by Europe’s fur industry association, Fur Europe. Of particular concern to welfare advocates is that WelFur continues to allow the use of small wire cages, which don’t allow animals to run, swim, or climb as they would in the wild and often cause boredom that results in tail-biting and fur-chewing.

WelFur spokesman Mick Madsen says that minks on farms don’t need to be able to express all the same behaviors as minks in the wild. He says that WelFur’s protocols are based on science and will be revised every five years to incorporate the newest research on animal welfare.

Regardless, welfare concerns on European farms pale in comparison to conditions on many Chinese ones.

The goal of any animal welfare regulation is to prevent unnecessary suffering. But for many animal advocates, fur farming begins and ends with the basic moral test of necessity—we don’t need fur clothing and accessories, and therefore fur farming for that purpose is immoral.

“Fur is a luxury item. Fur is not essential to human health or well-being,” says Oxford University ethicist Andrew Linzey, author of Why Animal Suffering Matters. “Causing suffering for fur is morally beyond the pale.”

Ethicists and philosophers argue that humans benefit from living in a society in which cruelty is discouraged. Animals, like children, have a special moral claim on humans because they’re morally innocent, unable to give consent or advocate for themselves. The law’s role is to defend the weak and vulnerable from exploitation, and that includes animals, Linzey says. “It’s morally parochial to think that only human suffering matters. Since we know that [animals] experience not just pain, but also mental suffering ... it’s inconsistent to oppose the deliberate infliction of suffering on humans but not also animals.”

Farming Minks

Minks are carnivorous mammals in the weasel family native to North America. Their silky fur has kept people warm since at least the 11th century.

“A mink coat is the coat to many women—and to growing numbers of men,” says Fur Commission USA, the United States’ primary fur trade organization.

Perhaps for that reason, the production of mink furs has shifted from trapping in the wild to farming in captivity. Through the use of selective breeding, fur farmers have produced minks in shades of black, auburn, cream, and silver.

China’s 35 million pelts accounted for about 40 percent of the market in 2014, according to the International Fur Federation. In comparison, the next biggest producer, Denmark, produced 17.8 million that year, according to Fur Europe, the umbrella organization that represents Europe’s fur industry, followed by Poland (8.5 million), the Netherlands (5.5 million), and Finland (2.5 million). The U.S., also a major producer, contributed about 3.75 million mink pelts, the U.S. Department of Agriculture reported.

Mink farming, welfare advocates say, poses insurmountable conundrums. These animals are highly territorial, solitary in the wild except during mating time. Minks in the wild spend their days roaming and swimming. What does it do to a mink to be crammed into close quarters with hundreds of others, bombarded by the scents of their feces and urine?

Minks “cannot respond appropriately to these chemical messages and the impacts on their welfare are unknown, but allowing feces to build up under cages has been identified as a potential cause of social stress,” says a report produced by the anti-fur group Respect for Animals and co-authored by Stephen Harris, a professor at Bristol University, in England, who was asked to do a scientific review of animal welfare standards.

On fur farms—even the more regulated ones in Europe, the U.S., and Canada—minks are confined to relatively small wire cages with little enrichment. Even when provided objects for entertainment, studies have found that it’s not enough to stop abnormal behaviors reflective of boredom and stress, such as pacing, fur chewing, and gnawing on the cage.

China’s Unregulated Industry

China’s fur farming industry came under pressure with the release of the 2005 Care for the Wild report, which was accompanied by videos from Swiss Animal Protection that appeared to show an animal being skinned alive. The international fur industry was quick to denounce the videos as fake, but it was nevertheless a watershed moment that prompted China to adopt new rules that require animals be stunned before they’re skinned.

Still, says Peter Li, a professor of East Asian politics at the University of Houston-Downtown and a China expert at Humane Society International, which opposes fur farming, those rules haven’t transformed Chinese fur farming. Cruelty and inhumane treatment remain rife.

That’s because under Chinese law, animals on fur farms are considered economic animals, “a tool for human use and source of income,” Li says. China’s forestry administration, agricultural ministry, and the fur industry association work together to come up with regulations, but welfare has never been a priority. “Chinese authorities have so far paid scant attention to animal welfare on the factory farms and fur farms,” Li says. “Productivity takes precedence over anything else.”

The association that represents China's fur industry did not respond to a request for comment.

A New Attempt to Improve European Farms

In the 2000s, leaders in the European fur industry began noticing that customers were demanding something new—reassurance about the welfare of animals raised to make their garments.

The European Council, an arm of the EU, has placed few demands on fur farms. A Council directive states that an animal can’t be farmed unless it can be kept “without detrimental effect on its health or welfare.” EU regulations protecting farm animals also apply to fur animals, but beyond such general legislation, there are no specific EU guidelines for animal welfare on fur farms, with the exception of some regulations on how animals on fur farms are to be killed. The Council of Europe, a non-EU body, issued recommendations in 1999 for protecting animal welfare on fur farms, but recommendations do not have the force of law.

That’s where WelFur comes in. The program is a joint effort between the European Fur Breeders Association and the International Fur Federation. In 2009 they began working out a monitoring system, and by 2014 protocols for mink and fox were complete. The program is now in the field-testing phase, and Fur Europe spokesman Mick Madsen says it will roll out officially in January 2017.

WelFur guidelines cover feeding, housing, health, and behavior. Conniff, the National Geographic reporter, accompanied an agronomist who helped develop WelFur on an inspection of a mink farm in Denmark: "He checked the nest box attached to each cage for size and the amount of straw for winter insulation. He examined the animals for body condition, injuries, and repeated back-and-forth motions that indicate stress. He inserted a tongue depressor in each cage to see if the animal responded with fear, aggression, or curiosity. A WelFur visit requires about six hours to inspect a 120-cage sample for 22 features."

Madsen says WelFur still hasn’t resolved what the penalty will be for farms that don’t pass a WelFur assessment. Fur Europe can’t throw out an individual farm for failing because the farms themselves are not members of Fur Europe, only their national fur breeders’ associations are. “There will be a consequence, but what exactly it is is still being discussed,” Madsen says.

WelFur is based on “best current practices,” and animal welfare advocates say those current practices are often inhumane—especially when it comes to housing.

“Since ‘best current practice’ involves the use of a farming system with low welfare potential, even the farms that score highest on the WelFur protocols will be providing a standard of welfare that most people would not consider acceptable,” says the Respect for Animals report that reviewed welfare standards.

That it’s inhumane to keep animals in small wire cages is just common sense, says Mark Glover, director of Respect for Animals.

Fur Europe’s Madsen brushes off the report as a product of “animal liberationists” who won’t be satisfied until fur farming is banned everywhere.

Great Britain, Austria, Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Slovenia, and the Netherlands have passed bans on fur farming (the Dutch ban has been appealed to the Supreme Court). Switzerland has such strict regulations that fur farming isn’t pursued there, and several other countries have passed bans on the farming of certain species.

This story was produced by National Geographic’s Special Investigations Unit, which focuses on wildlife crime and is made possible by grants from the BAND Foundation and the Woodtiger Fund. Read more stories from the SIU on Wildlife Watch. Send tips, feedback, and story ideas to ngwildlife@natgeo.com.

Read This Next

What drives elephant poaching? It’s not greed
How old are you, really? The answer is written on your face.
The rise of vegan safaris

Go Further

Subscriber Exclusive Content

Why are people so dang obsessed with Mars?

How viruses shape our world

The era of greyhound racing in the U.S. is coming to an end

See how people have imagined life on Mars through history

See how NASA’s new Mars rover will explore the red planet

Why are people so dang obsessed with Mars?

How viruses shape our world

The era of greyhound racing in the U.S. is coming to an end

See how people have imagined life on Mars through history

See how NASA’s new Mars rover will explore the red planet

Why are people so dang obsessed with Mars?

How viruses shape our world

The era of greyhound racing in the U.S. is coming to an end

See how people have imagined life on Mars through history

See how NASA’s new Mars rover will explore the red planet