National Geographic Logo - Home
    Partner Content for Meiji University
    surreal optical illusion, man change his point of view
    • Science
    • News

    When circles are finally squared

    There is a mathematical side to optical illusions. One professor studies them in hopes of creating a safer world.

    Man on a roof or ladder against the wall: either way, it just doesn't seem possible in real life. Or is it?
    Illustration by frankie's, Shutterstock
    This is Paid Content. The editorial staff of National Geographic was not involved in the preparation or production of this content.

    You may have heard the saying, “you can’t square a circle”, which is essentially metaphor for trying to do the impossible. Yet, world-renowned illusion researcher Kokichi Sugihara of Meiji University has uncovered the solution to this problem.

    Unlike the more common approaches of studying illusion such as human psychology and cognition, Sugihara has taken a mathematical approach to understanding illusional depth. Unraveling the mathematical side to illusion, Sugihara believes, would potentially decrease the hazards of optical illusions, in situations like driving for example.

    For 42 years, Sugihara has worked on devising mathematical formulae to prove the existence of “impossible objects”: 3D recreations of illustrations representing geometric motion that cannot physically happen. The three-time winner for Best Illusion of the Year has produced 500 mathematically-designed deceptions to date.

    two intersecting L-shapes making up an "impossible object".
    The brain cannot fathom how an optical illusion can manifest in real life, rendering it "impossible".
    Photograph courtesy Meiji University
    Please be respectful of copyright. Unauthorized use is prohibited.

    Take for instance the illustration of two L-shaped blocks. Given the thickness of each block, it is inconceivable that such intersecting blocks could exist in reality. This is because when the brain tries to picture three-dimensional structures out of two-dimensional images, it can only make out objects with faces that are connected in 90-degree angles – like structures we are used to seeing in real life – rendering it “impossible” recreate physically. Or so we think. The disconnect is due to a lack of depth perception and such impossible objects can be demystified once viewed from a different angle.

    a 3D recreation of a 2-dimensional "impossible object".
    Please be respectful of copyright. Unauthorized use is prohibited.
    a 3D recreation of a 2-dimensional "impossible object".
    Please be respectful of copyright. Unauthorized use is prohibited.
    "Impossible objects" are revealed to be "possible" when viewed from different angles in 3D.
    Photographs courtesy Meiji University

    Another area of Sugihara’s research is “ambiguous objects”, which includes the groundbreaking study of a square-circle visual paradox. Cylinders that originally appeared round magically appear squarish when viewed in the mirror.

    “How can an object be both square and circular?” Sugihara asks. “The existence of such geometry-defying objects warns us of the potential dangers of optical illusions in our lives.”

    cylinders that appear squarish in the mirror.
    Please be respectful of copyright. Unauthorized use is prohibited.
    a rounded roof of a toy garage appearing angular in the mirror.
    Please be respectful of copyright. Unauthorized use is prohibited.
    Left: An "ambiguous object" is one with different appearances on either side.
    Right: The roof of this garage, which appears different in the mirror, is another example of an "ambiguous object".
    Photographs courtesy Meiji University

    Beyond static displays, Sugihara has also demonstrated how physical objects in the real world can sometimes behave in unexpected ways.

    Consider four slopes that appear to extend downwards from a common centre. When marbles are dropped on each slope, they appear to defy gravity by rolling uphill. No magnets are involved in this bizarre phenomenon, Sugihara assures; all that was needed was a play on the human visual system.

    Sugihara explains that as the human eye tends to interpret illustrations using right angles, the columns supporting the four anti-gravity slopes are perceived to be vertical. Even if we come to realize that the columns are in fact not vertical, we cannot “unsee” the illusion because that is how the brain is wired.

    Such bewildering trickery has given rise to “impossible motion”, a term coined by Sugihara in the mid-1990s. The famed mathematician has since created 50 examples of impossible motions including a yearly life-sized snow sledding display at the Hakkai-Sanroku Ski Resort in Niigata, Japan.

    Besides convincing mankind that such impossible objects do exist, Sugihara’s research has paved the way for potential applications such as enhancing road safety and equipping robots with better vision. However, he firmly believes that there is more to discover.

    Professor Kokichi Sugihara of Meiji University.
    Professor Kokichi Sugihara of Meiji University has spent 42 years using mathematics to unravel the mysteries behind optical illusion.
    Photograph courtesy Meiji University
    Please be respectful of copyright. Unauthorized use is prohibited.

    “While I have proposed countermeasures to help reduce optical illusion, especially on the roads, there are many other factors at play such as human psychology,” Sugihara observes. “More research needs to be done.”



    Read This Next

    • Paid Content

    A new sensation: recording and reproducing taste

    Meiji University scientist has found a way to reproduce taste, just as we’ve long been able to do for sight and sound.
    • Paid Content

    Origami gets a second life

    A centuries-old Japanese art is set to revolutionize the manufacturing industry with origami printing.
    Million-year-old mammoth teeth yield world's oldest DNA
    • Science

    Million-year-old mammoth teeth yield world's oldest DNA

    The record-breaking genetic material is offering fresh insights into how North America’s mammoths lived and evolved.
    Why mapping Mars completely changed how we see it
    • Science
    • Nat Geo Explores

    Why mapping Mars completely changed how we see it

    Mars has drawn our attention for millennia, and it was when we started mapping the planet that we began to see it as a place, and a destination. Early mapmaking led to scientific discoveries—and a few far-fetched theories—which changed how we see the planet today.

    Legal

    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Your California Privacy Rights
    • Children's Online Privacy Policy
    • Interest-Based Ads
    • About Nielsen Measurement
    • Do Not Sell My Info

    Our Sites

    • Nat Geo Home
    • Attend a Live Event
    • Book a Trip
    • Buy Maps
    • Inspire Your Kids
    • Shop Nat Geo
    • Visit the D.C. Museum
    • Watch TV
    • Learn About Our Impact
    • Support our Mission
    • Nat Geo Partners
    • Masthead
    • Press Room
    • Advertise With Us

    Join Us

    • Subscribe
    • Customer Service
    • Renew Subscription
    • Manage Your Subscription
    • Work at NatGeo
    • Signup for Our Newsletters
    • Contribute to Protect the Planet
    • Pitch a Story

    Follow us


    National Geographic Logo - Home

    Copyright © 1996-2015 National Geographic SocietyCopyright © 2015-2023 National Geographic Partners, LLC. All rights reserved