Finding the Sublime on the John Muir Trail
In an excerpt from his new book Yosemite Falls, Daniel Duane ponders forgotten human histories in the High Sierra.

I walked with Jane in bright, clear sun under a dark blue sky to a backcountry cabin known as the Bench Lake Ranger Station. I’d agreed to walk with her east off the John Muir Trail, up a lateral pass called Taboose, atop which we would part ways: she, bound downhill toward the desert parking lot where she’d left her car; myself, back to the Muir Trail and onward. Beyond the ranger cabin, we did just that: right-hand turn off a branch path that took us across open tundra called the Upper Basin, crisscrossed with small tributary streams and lakes and some very interesting terminal and lateral moraines spotted with muted green alpine grasses and tiny flowers. A willow-lined creek crossed the trail.
Upstream, we found what any human being in any age would recognize as a campsite: a deep pool of clear water for washing; trees surrounding a pine-needle bed just big enough for a family. We pitched the tent, she filtered water, I made soup and tea, and we both noticed something unusual: from inside that little circle of pines, hidden to outsiders, we could see across a giant swath of open country, meadow and boulder, creek and tarn.
Jane noticed, atop a small white rock, two perfect arrowheads placed as if by hand in hopes that we would find them. Feeling something we couldn’t name, Jane and I walked out of those trees onto a knoll and found a view westward across tundra that, again, any human in any age would have recognized as commanding a vast landscape in air so clear that one could see every movement of every mountain grouse, pika, and marmot on sun-washed lawn and scattered granite, rock-garden stream and bonsai whitebark. A distant storm cloud tore itself apart on a distant peak. Like a perfect white moron, I thought, Gee, I bet Indians hung out around here. I glanced at the ground in a reflexive search for evidence and saw a tiny black chip of obsidian. Nearby, another, and another; tens of thousands, entire galaxies of tiny black stars in white micro-gravel. Obsidian does not occur naturally in the High Sierra. Every scrap I saw had to have been chipped off a larger block that had, in turn, been quarried somewhere below in the desert and carried up here to make dart points and arrowheads. Every scrap, therefore, meant labor and journey, flicking movements of arms and fingers.
Turning on my feet, then, looking eastward, I had one of the great emotional breakthroughs of my life—one of those rare moments when you feel as if the veil of delusion has been pulled aside. More concretely, I suddenly saw what I had not before, that Taboose Pass was itself an immense U-shaped natural opening in the giant jagged scarp of the eastern crest of the range—a doorway between realms, high country and low, desert and mountain. Spinning to look westward again . . . that vast open basin rolled down and away from Taboose like an enormous funnel draining into the south fork of the river currently called Kings and on through the natural highways of bending canyon and pine slope into foothill savannah and big river to the sea.
Taboose Pass, in other words, suddenly revealed itself to me as that rarest of things, a place where any human being east of that great mountain range—single biggest obstacle to east-west travel across the western half of North America—could hike a single giant slope up out of hot sage and creosote into the realm of cold stone, crest a single pass over the crest of the range, and thereby enter a soaring open high plateau from which to walk and ramble downhill clear into the San Joaquin and out to the Pacific. So, of course there was a lot of obsidian here, because of course people had always used Taboose Pass—but, see, this latter of course meant also that of course anything called a John Muir Trail (regardless of whether or not a guy by that name ever walked it) really was a remarkable species of abstraction created not by ancient, traditional, nor even obvious human use of landscape but rather by an extremely recent (in geological time) American impulse to draw a line on a map between one place famous only for a barometric/altimeter reading (Mount Whitney), which itself only had real significance relative to abstract political boundaries (highest peak in the lower forty-eight), and another for admittedly terrific waterfalls and cliffs, across a landscape that we’d agreed to consider Place Without Past, Temple of Forgetting.
The sunset wind turned cold. Gold-black clouds billowed in the falling darkness, so Jane and I crawled together into the little blue tent, lit a candle in the lantern. Lying beside Jane in my stinky sleeping bag, I thought maybe this was why I’d been having so much trouble getting my Muir on: I not only had blindly accepted the now dubious notion of the Muir Trail as Muir’s trail, but I also had accepted that it was an authentic wilderness pilgrimage. Then I got into the mountains and, partly due to my own troubled psychology and partly due to the undeniably perverse course taken by the Muir Trail up and down all those gigantic mountain passes, suspected otherwise. Now, to make matters worse—or, really, better—I had ineluctable evidence of what an authentic High Sierra passage might actually look like, in terms of how the human mind and body used and moved through landforms.
The human mind and body did not, in other words, look at giant north-south mountain ranges and think, I know—let’s walk the entire thing lengthwise with seventy pounds on our backs, taking care to gain and lose as much elevation as possible every step of the way. The human mind-body saw a north- south range and thought, rather, Hmm, how can we get up into the pretty? Or, How can we get across? In fact, I was even then looking with my own eyes at one answer to that very question: Taboose Pass, clearly used by human beings for eons before some genius got the idea for a John Muir Trail, which I now suspected might not really be a John Muir Trail in any meaningful sense at all.
Far from a bummer, though, I found this all marvelous, exhilarating—so, too, the fact that the Muir Trail itself, by rolling right on past so much obsidian as if it wasn’t there, put the double lie to the old line from a Sierra Club president about the trail being a highway for devout pilgrims blessing the memory of the prophet who was the first to sing the praises of this glorious sequence of mountain, meadow, pass, and lake. It all suggested such violent amnesia, an aggressive will to see the absolute absence of a human past in a place where there was clearly quite a bit. Clarence King sang the praises ten years before Muir, but far more to the point, did anyone really think that nobody in how many thousands of years of human habitation ever found the Sierra Nevada pretty and said so? And because White People Like Us came out here to “leave it all behind”—to live, in some sense, in a fusion of pioneer westering fantasy and Renaissance Indigenous critique of European lifestyle (Indigenous North Americans regularly pointed out to Renaissance Europeans that their whole system of property ownership and land use produced a remarkably miserable existence)—to let oneself see deep history right there at one’s feet would be, well . . . hardly the point. Wise, arguably, to set aside land for escape from all histories personal and collective, from private sufferings and communal frustrations, intimate humiliations and public disappointments. Miraculous, even, to cordon off a sanctuary for present-tense wind-in-the-pines, shooting stars, and Venus glittering like a diamond set with a crescent moon.
But, see (and this is where something characterological comes into play), some native paranoia of mine to the effect that I’m always being gaslit, hypnotized into not seeing something obvious—interacting, in this case and at that odd moment of life, with my undying love for the Sierra Nevada and undeniable sense of alienation, plus my will to overcome the latter by knowing the place on my own terms, independent from historical hallucination/lie—maybe I didn’t want to live that way. So, then, back to all those many thousands of bits of obsidian, evidence of sustained use over a long period of time (and therefore history, drama, love and loss), lying right there in plain sight near the Muir Trail, unmarked and unstudied like so many deer droppings. It all prompted a serious question, in other words, that I have since come to recognize as a core characterological impulse of my own. To wit: What were we all trying not to see?
Jane was right there with me, flipping out a little as we lay together in the tent. Something about that much obsidian in plain sight, unstudied in our ancient age of the sun, conjured for both of us intimations of tragedy, things deliberately not known. So, we crawled awkwardly back into the cold night air, in socks and thermal underwear, jointly thanked whoever truly owned our campsite for allowing us to be there and not troubling our dreams. We said we knew we were visitors, felt no claim. I had some vague memory of fur-trapper narratives in which people offered tobacco to imaginary spirits, so I rolled a cigarette and laid it on a stone, poured out whiskey. Jane waved our candle lantern three times, and then both of us, for lack of a better idea, said, Thank you.